An Ecumenical Recipe Pairing

Most New Englanders believe chowder should be creamy and cream-colored, and that version has been around since at least the 1830s. But leave it to New Yorkers to reinvent something and call it their own.

Every couple of years, I feel called upon to write a diatribe about what passes for clam chowder in many, if not most, local restaurants. What is served is often a thick white paste containing canned clams and – horror of horrors – chopped canned or frozen potatoes, along with a few onions and a sprinkling of stale paprika.

Some boast of their chowder being thick enough to stand up a spoon. Any chowder that will stand up a spoon is not worth eating, in my not-so-humble opinion. I find these concoctions to be abominations unfit for man, and only maybe fit for beasts.

In France, you are not allowed to label any loaf as “bread” if it contains anything beyond these ingredients: flour, yeast, salt and water. I would like to see a similarly restrictive list of ingredients for any soup called clam chowder. The ingredients should be limited to clams, potatoes, onions, salt pork, butter, flour, some form of milk, and seasonings.

I recently heard a lady from Nantucket on the radio expressing her outrage at people putting adulterants like celery and leeks in their chowder. She even found the use of cream in a chowder to be pretentious. Chowder has been a mainstay of the diets of Nantucket’s denizens for centuries. In Herman Melville’s classic novel of the whaling trade, the protagonist, Ishmael, and his cohort and harpooner, Queequeg, board at an inn on Nantucket before sailing. The men were offered two dishes, both chowders. The only choice was clam or cod. You can bet that you couldn’t stand a spoon up in either one of these. If you could, you would have mutiny on your hands.

I don’t want to discuss the clam-flavored tomato soup served in Rhode Island and points west to Manhattan, and I don’t refer to them as chowder at all. It can be a fine soup, but it is not a chowder in my world.

Here, once again, using the ingredients I have listed, is my recipe that my old, now dead friend Captain Gene Crocker, tugboat man, described as “clam chowder the way God meant it to be.”


Recipe: Clam Chowder “The Way God Intended”

  • 2 cups clam meats, ground
  • 2 lbs. potatoes
  • 1 medium onion, minced
  • 4 oz. salt pork, diced
  • 2 TBS butter
  • 1 ½ cups whole milk
  • 1 can evaporated milk (or one cup cream)
  • salt and pepper
  • ¼ tsp. Tabasco
  • A pinch of thyme

I like to steam the clams myself so that I have clam broth in which to boil the potatoes. If you do not make your own clam broth, use bottled clam broth.

In a heavy kettle, render salt pork over a medium flame until opaque. When enough fat has been rendered, add minced onion and sauté until opaque. If you like a thickened chowder, now is the time to add flour to your salt pork and onion mixture to make a roux, stirring at least two minutes to cook away any floury taste.

While you have been doing the above, you should have your potatoes boiling in clam broth. Add your boiled potatoes and the broth they cooked in to the roux and stir until smooth, then add the ground clams, pepper, and Tabasco. There you have your chowder base.

I like to thoroughly cool this base and refrigerate it overnight, adding the milk and pinch of thyme just before serving. Be careful not to boil your chowder, as it might (will) separate.

I like to serve the chowder in a warm bowl to which I have added a pat of butter, sprinkled with a bit of paprika.

I was saddened to read recently that Maine sea biscuits, which are thick, round crackers, are no longer being produced. These crackers were added by the diner to thicken a chowder, but alas – they are no more. Oyster crackers or saltines can partially fill the void left by the sinking of the sea biscuit.


In the current trend toward seeking national unity under a new political regime, I think publishing a recipe for Manhattan clam soup, often erroneously called chowder, is in order. This recipe can be found in The Silver Palate Cookbook by Rosso and Lukins.

Recipe: Manhattan Clam Soup

  • 4 TBS sweet butter
  • 2 cups finely chopped yellow onions
  • 1 cup chopped celery
  • 5 cups chicken stock
  • 1 ½ tsp. thyme
  • 1 bay leaf
  • salt and pepper
  • 1 large can Italian tomatoes chopped after draining
  • 1 cup chopped Italian (flat-leaf) parsley
  • 2 medium-sized boiling potatoes, peeled and diced
  • 3 dozen small clams (about 2 cups clam meat)
  • Grated orange zest (optional garnish)

Melt butter in a large pot. Add onions and celery and cook covered over low heat for about 20 minutes, or until lightly colored. Add all remaining ingredients except clams and orange zest, and bring to a boil. Reduce heat and simmer for 30 minutes, until potatoes are very tender.

Meanwhile, scrub your clams and steam open; use about an inch of water in the bottom of a pot just big enough to hold them. Drain pot, saving clam liquid for future use. Remove clams from shells and grind, mince or process until desired texture is achieved.

Add clams to other ingredients, taste for seasoning (I like to add a little hot sauce), and serve with orange zest on the side for optional garnishing. Crackers are also appropriate here.

I wonder if Captain Crocker is turning in his grave, having been mentioned in a column alongside Manhattan clam chowder!

Looking For A Great Fish Chowder Recipe?

tautog-featuredMaster Thy Chowder
Whether you call them blackfish or tautog, these goofy-looking bottom fish make for a great chowder.

Other Great On the Water Recipes

Cooking The Catch 1 and 2Cooking The Catch 1 & 2 Combo
Get both of these well written and resourceful cookbooks for one reduced price. Hundreds of great recipes for local seafood.

8 on “An Ecumenical Recipe Pairing

  1. Bill

    I am shocked and personally offended that you would suggest that we Rhode Islanders would make or serve “Manhattan Chowder”. We make our chowders clear and unadulterated. There is no cream, milk or thickeners added. It gives you a more pure clam flavor. Mind you, this personal offense isn’t as bad as the time I went to California and ordered the New England clam chowder (for my own personal entertainment) at a premier seafood place. It was made with mussels, razor clams and conch. It tasted good, but it was definitely NOT New England Chowder.

    1. ed

      I am actually a fan of that clear RI chowder also. I think it has a much greater clam flavor than when cut with milk or cream. I will eat the NE version as long as its watery and I agree that if you can stand a spoon in it, then its better served for use as a footing.

  2. Paul

    I’ve lived in RI all my life (37) and never even seen red clam soup or whatever you call it. Here its either clam chowder or the clear quahog chowder. I like both equally.

  3. chris

    chowder goes back to england france in the 16th century, clams didnt enter the picture until 1850s or so. manhattan clam chowder is not a misnomer but what you call a soup of clam tomatoes and other vegetables. The use of chicken stock in clam chowder i find more offensive than anything you would call it lol. Clam juice, clam base, even fish shrimp or crab stock would be an upgrade.

  4. Mitch

    Pops thanks for the recipe for Chowder, followed it to the tee kinda but it was the best chowder I ever made. Thanks On the Water for keeping this memory alive.

  5. jake

    worked 24 + years @ a quincy,ma oil terminal, and spent many, many hours on the bridge of the exxon baystate with gene and/or donny spring. those hours are among my best memories, and gene’s chowder recipe is even better than my grandmother’s . miss you gene.

  6. Barry Reil

    If God had meant for clam chowder to be red, He (She) would have given clams blood.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *